Out of 6 subcompact cars, Consumer Reports likes 3, hates 3

With gas prices the way they are these days, subcompact cars are becoming more and more enticing to customers hoping to save money on fuel. Not only do subcompact cars offer excellent fuel economy, they typically come with lower sticker prices. This is true whether you plan to buy a new or used vehicle.

Consumer Reports is currently tracking six subcompact cars. The issue is split evenly between three who give a thumbs up and three who criticize more harshly. Which cars fall into which category?